Make the016.com a preferred choice with Google by clicking here
A Granada Hills, Calif., resident tries to save his home from a recent fire. AP Photo/Michael Owen Baker
Alexander Smith, Worcester Polytechnic Institute
As California’s wildfire season intensifies, a growing number of residents in the state want to ban people from building in areas at greatest risk.
That’s because taxpayers bear the burden of protecting homes in dangerous areas when fire breaks out – and they often help foot the bill when it’s time to rebuild. A recent assessment showed that 1 in 4 Californians live in an area at “high risk” of wildfire. And people tend to want to rebuild in the same spot that was hit by a disaster.
As a behavioral economist who studies the psychology of decision-making, I try to understand people’s motivations before taking a position in a policy debate. I believe there’s a better way for policymakers to achieve the same goal of getting people to avoid building in disaster-prone areas without forcing people from their homes.
In behavioral economics, there’s something known as the endowment effect.
The endowment effect is basically the idea that people overvalue things they already own. And it helps explain the common and seemingly irrational desire of many homeowners to rebuild in places at great risk of wildfire, hurricanes or other natural disasters.
Behavioral economists Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler were the first to explain this effect in 1990. They conducted an experiment in which half their subjects were given a coffee mug. They asked those subjects to name the lowest price at which they’d be willing to sell their mug. They then asked those without mugs how much they would be willing to pay buy one.
Since the subjects who received a mug were randomly chosen, there should have been little difference between the selling and buying prices, which represent how each group valued the mug.
Instead, the researchers discovered a significant gap between two groups. The median selling price, representing the people who already had mugs, was US$5.79, more than double the $2.25 people were willing to pay. The conclusion is that someone with an item values it a lot more than someone who does not have it regardless of their actual preferences.
In the context of California wildfires or other natural disasters, the endowment effect says that someone who owns a damaged or destroyed home will have a strong preference for rebuilding over moving somewhere else.
To ignore this preference by putting an outright ban on rebuilding disregards the wishes of these people. It also squanders the potential impact of increased economic activity as a result of the new construction. Areas recovering from disaster are in great need of this kind of stimulus.
At the same time, I don’t think we should stand idly by and watch people continue to build homes in disaster zones. Such an approach creates an unfair burden for the state, which spends a significant amount of money providing disaster relief to affected areas.
Rather, my view – which is common among economists – is that the best policy when an activity imposes costs on society is to create a pricing system that pushes those costs back onto the individuals responsible.
With fuel for gas-guzzling vehicles, for example, the best policy is a tax equal to the cost that the pollution causes for society – this is how carbon pricing works. Such taxes are called Pigouvian taxes after economist Arthur Pigou, who developed the concept of “externalities” – or the unrelated side effects of some economic activity.
In the case of disaster zones, municipal property taxes need to reflect the additional costs of public services like disaster relief that are often provided by state and federal authorities. Governments can then use the extra revenue to finance disaster mitigation efforts or other initiatives in the public interest.
The key thing is that the tax creates a disincentive to engage in the undesirable activity short of an outright ban. And research shows these kinds of taxes are effective.
A challenge with the implementation of such a policy is that it is hard to assess the costs of relief in advance.
However, the insurance industry is very good at risk and cost assessment, and governments can use their methods to achieve the right pricing mechanism. The additional property taxes that would result would make living in disaster-prone areas more costly – and some people would certainly be willing to bear this burden – but this is what society needs in order to reduce the activity.
This softer approach, which could achieve the same ends as a heavy-handed ban, is a much better way to create a financial incentive for people to avoid rebuilding in dangerous parts of the country – saving taxpayer dollars and avoiding the inconvenience of preemptive blackouts like we’ve seen recently in California.
[ Expertise in your inbox. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter and get a digest of academic takes on today’s news, every day. ]<!-- Below is The Conversation's page counter tag. Please DO NOT REMOVE. -->
<!-- End of code. If you don't see any code above, please get new code from the Advanced tab after you click the republish button. The page counter does not collect any personal data. More info: http://theconversation.com/republishing-guidelines -->
Alexander Smith, Associate Professor of Economics, Worcester Polytechnic Institute
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
In The News
>WEATHER: Mark Rosenthal's 7-day forecast (:43). High of 60 today in Worcester
>TOP OF THE NEWS
-New developer picks up stalled housing plan near Polar Park
-Crews rush to Lake Quinsig after report of vehicle in water
-Worcester mirrors national rise in food insecurity
-A Decade of Love: How a family turned grief into a legacy of giving
-Community Advocate Hometown Helper: Jacqueline Monteiro, Keeping Worcester Warm
-Free holiday parking returns to Worcester starting Saturday
-Nuclear submariner, habitual volunteer, Shrewsbury icon: Bob Holland can’t "sit idly by"
-New Ronald McDonald Care Mobile brings health care to Worcester neighborhoods
-Worcester man accused of murder after allegedly confessing to shooting his wife in the face, claims self-defense (:26). Article
-Could these never-before-seen videos help solve Holly's Piirainen’s 1993 murder? (3:49). Article
-Worcester Police Department log for Thursday, November 19th
-Why are utility bills so high? Channel 25 followed the money (3:36)
>FAITH: Resisting Anti-Judaism: Practices of Christian Solidarity (55:53)
>DINING OUT: Phantom Gourmet's Great 8 calzones (5:42)
-Turn up the heat on your restaurant's social media — without burning through your budget!
-These Worcester restaurants are open Thanksgiving, but get your reservation in
-ICYMI: Suspect arrested after unresponsive man wakes up and punches Worcester firefighter
-Families celebrate National Adoption Day in Massachusetts (:41). Article
-Puppy rescued from dumpster in Rutland leads to animal cruelty charges (1:37). Article
-New Worcester Holiday Market brings 150 vendors downtown for 8 days
-WoMag at 50: "Focus on the writing" — One thing hasn't changed
See the rest of the day's Worcester news (brought to you by The Arbella at Bramble Hill)
>HOLDEN (brought to you by The Arbella at Bramble Hill): Vacancy on Agricultural Commission
-Vacancy on Recreation Committee
>THE BURBS (brought to you by North End Motor Sales): Dudley man arrested on gun charges after hit-and-run in Auburn
-Webster P.D.: Level 3 sex offender arrested after failing to meet registration deadline
-Shrewsbury voters to weigh data center limits next month
-Their towns host massive data centers. Here's their advice for Sutton
-Lancaster Select Board to consider petition seeking ballot question on allowing package stores in town
-Haul-zilla: Large transformer moves through region
-Over a year after its closure, Whitney Street bridge in Northborough sees (some) progress with redesign
-Fitchburg school committee members split on approving their own pay
>BARS & BANDS: The Mayor's Live Music List for Sunday
>SHOWTIME: Worcester Comedy Friendsgiving Sunday
-Concert ticket prices: Where does the money go?
-Today! Musical Inspirations presents "Black Poetry in Song" on Sunday
-Trey Anastasio & Billy Strings in Worcester: A dreamy night of not knowing what came next
-At Tower Hill, it takes months of planning to turn on Night Lights
-WCCA-TV's Chris's Corner No. 35 (28:22): Meatball and Chris talk about May 15th, 2027 event, Part 1
>OPINION: Shaun Connolly: Miss the old Kelley Square?
-Laurel: A Thanksgiving Day Parade, Worcester style
-WCCA-TV's Soapbox No. 1429 (26:03): Kristy Glover, Professor of Criminal Justice and documentarian
-Radio Worcester's The Rundown (26:13): Worcester camping ordinance and Sutton data center plan
-Radio Worcester Roundtable (54:35): Worcester police drone proposal draws debate
>OBITUARIES: Tribute to 26-year veteran of the Worcester Police Department
>SPORTS: Should Patriots sign a quarterback? A.J. Brown’s future and more
-NFL Week 11 schedule, TV and announcers
-Bruins beat Washington, 7-5
-Celtics lose to Sacramento, 97-96
-Sonny Gray bolts Red Sox for $55 million Twins deal
-Holy Cross football team beats Fordham, 20-10. Postgame press conference (1:02)
-Holy Cross' Carlo Crocetti’s determination leads to success on, off gridiron
-Holy Cross men's hockey falls to No. 8 Quinnipiac
-Holy Cross women's basketball travels to face Richmond on Sunday
-Assumption football and field hockey teams win conference championships
>NATIONAL: Multiple killed in mass shooting at baby shower
-Court approves billion dollar settlement with Bayer over Roundup weed killer
-Tragic: Family of 4 found dead after daughter made haunting 911 call
>NEW ENGLAND: Channel 25 probes claims of "no show" Mass. D.O.T. inspector (4:23). Article
-Massachusetts midterm turnout tops 2.7 million voters
>COLLEGES: This is Holy Cross (:31)
-WPI named a leader in study abroad
>TRAVEL (brought to you by Fuller RV & Rental): Thanksgiving travelers consider changing plans amid woes (2:30)
>BUSINESS: How vulnerable is Worcester to A.I. job losses?
-How to protect your information following a cyber attack
-Massive Whitinsville mill complex sold for $13.2 million
-Food distribution nonprofit purchases Westborough property for $2.2 million
>SHOPPING: Oprah’s Favorite Things turns 30. Here are 4 gifts under $60
>HOMES: A year in, New England heat pump program is thriving
>HEALTH: Researchers developing pill that could detect 30 common cancers
-Researchers explore sleep disorder linked to Parkinson's, dementia (2:36)
>FOOD: Pastas, breakfast foods, whipped cream and more recalled across U.S.
>TV/STREAMING: Dozens of CBS News staffers leaving after voluntary buyouts
>MOVIES: Sisters Elle and Dakota Fanning star in new movie, "The Nightingale" (2:38)
>CELEBRITY: Sylvester Stallone reflects on "very contentious" Arnold Schwarzenegger feud
-Jennifer Lawrence proudly shows off her "new" breast implants to Andy Cohen
>ANIMALS: Woman checks in on dog she never forgot, gets best surprise (3:33)
>HISTORY: The surprising history of swearing in the U.S.
>GOOD NEWS: Daughter helps man pick $100,000-winning Powerball numbers
-Meanwhile, Google Earth image captures mysterious figures under Loch Ness' surface
Latest obituaries | | Saturday's Highlights | | Today's horoscope | | Local Sports
Quick Links: Personalize your news | | Browse members | | Advertise | | Blogs | | Invite friends | | Videos
Animals | | Boston Sports | | Business | | Cars | | Celebrity | | Colleges | | Commute & Travel | | Crime | | Faith | | Food | | Good News | | Health | | Help Wanted | History | | Homes | | Local Sports | | Lottery | | Movies | | National | | New England | | Politics | | Shopping & Deals | | SHOWTIME! | | TV & Streaming | | Weather
Comments