A Granada Hills, Calif., resident tries to save his home from a recent fire. AP Photo/Michael Owen Baker
Alexander Smith, Worcester Polytechnic Institute
As California’s wildfire season intensifies, a growing number of residents in the state want to ban people from building in areas at greatest risk.
That’s because taxpayers bear the burden of protecting homes in dangerous areas when fire breaks out – and they often help foot the bill when it’s time to rebuild. A recent assessment showed that 1 in 4 Californians live in an area at “high risk” of wildfire. And people tend to want to rebuild in the same spot that was hit by a disaster.
As a behavioral economist who studies the psychology of decision-making, I try to understand people’s motivations before taking a position in a policy debate. I believe there’s a better way for policymakers to achieve the same goal of getting people to avoid building in disaster-prone areas without forcing people from their homes.
In behavioral economics, there’s something known as the endowment effect.
The endowment effect is basically the idea that people overvalue things they already own. And it helps explain the common and seemingly irrational desire of many homeowners to rebuild in places at great risk of wildfire, hurricanes or other natural disasters.
Behavioral economists Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler were the first to explain this effect in 1990. They conducted an experiment in which half their subjects were given a coffee mug. They asked those subjects to name the lowest price at which they’d be willing to sell their mug. They then asked those without mugs how much they would be willing to pay buy one.
Since the subjects who received a mug were randomly chosen, there should have been little difference between the selling and buying prices, which represent how each group valued the mug.
Instead, the researchers discovered a significant gap between two groups. The median selling price, representing the people who already had mugs, was US$5.79, more than double the $2.25 people were willing to pay. The conclusion is that someone with an item values it a lot more than someone who does not have it regardless of their actual preferences.
In the context of California wildfires or other natural disasters, the endowment effect says that someone who owns a damaged or destroyed home will have a strong preference for rebuilding over moving somewhere else.
To ignore this preference by putting an outright ban on rebuilding disregards the wishes of these people. It also squanders the potential impact of increased economic activity as a result of the new construction. Areas recovering from disaster are in great need of this kind of stimulus.
At the same time, I don’t think we should stand idly by and watch people continue to build homes in disaster zones. Such an approach creates an unfair burden for the state, which spends a significant amount of money providing disaster relief to affected areas.
Rather, my view – which is common among economists – is that the best policy when an activity imposes costs on society is to create a pricing system that pushes those costs back onto the individuals responsible.
With fuel for gas-guzzling vehicles, for example, the best policy is a tax equal to the cost that the pollution causes for society – this is how carbon pricing works. Such taxes are called Pigouvian taxes after economist Arthur Pigou, who developed the concept of “externalities” – or the unrelated side effects of some economic activity.
In the case of disaster zones, municipal property taxes need to reflect the additional costs of public services like disaster relief that are often provided by state and federal authorities. Governments can then use the extra revenue to finance disaster mitigation efforts or other initiatives in the public interest.
The key thing is that the tax creates a disincentive to engage in the undesirable activity short of an outright ban. And research shows these kinds of taxes are effective.
A challenge with the implementation of such a policy is that it is hard to assess the costs of relief in advance.
However, the insurance industry is very good at risk and cost assessment, and governments can use their methods to achieve the right pricing mechanism. The additional property taxes that would result would make living in disaster-prone areas more costly – and some people would certainly be willing to bear this burden – but this is what society needs in order to reduce the activity.
This softer approach, which could achieve the same ends as a heavy-handed ban, is a much better way to create a financial incentive for people to avoid rebuilding in dangerous parts of the country – saving taxpayer dollars and avoiding the inconvenience of preemptive blackouts like we’ve seen recently in California.
[ Expertise in your inbox. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter and get a digest of academic takes on today’s news, every day. ]<!-- Below is The Conversation's page counter tag. Please DO NOT REMOVE. --><!-- End of code. If you don't see any code above, please get new code from the Advanced tab after you click the republish button. The page counter does not collect any personal data. More info: http://theconversation.com/republishing-guidelines -->
Alexander Smith, Associate Professor of Economics, Worcester Polytechnic Institute
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
In The News
>WEATHER: Mark Rosenthal's 7-day forecast (1:14). High of 53 today in Worcester
>TOP OF THE NEWS
+5:00: Worcester firm charged with patient abuse, fraud and money laundering
+5:00: Kamryn Richard visits the WXLO studios and talks bid for "American Idol"
+1:00: Worcester police seek homes for rescued dogs
+1:00: Worcester to lose $1.5 million in federal funding
+1:00: Worcester singer Angelo Gray, 11, set to appear in "Running Man"
+1:00: Polar reveals summer 2025 limited-edition seltzer flavors
+1:00: Screen Time: Celebrating the time the Three Stooges came to Worcester
+1:00: Clark prof's documentary on Latin jazz great Omar Sosa now on Amazon
+1:00: Janice Harvey: Local protests against Musk, DOGE are picking up steam
+1:00: Opening of transfer portal has heavy implications for Holy Cross men’s basketball
-Worcester police ask for help finding missing 12-year-old
-4 indicted in December murder on Dorchester Street in Worcester
-Area man banned from all Walmarts after shoplifting with bag of Percocet intended for sale
-Racist "poem" circulating at Leicester High under investigation, superintendent says
-Need legal help in Worcester? Head to the Law Library on Main Street
-T&G Student of Week: Recognizing high achievers
-Worcester city councilor threatens lawsuit over "retaliation"
-Mike Benedetti: Worcester City Council meeting agenda
-After grabbing shoulder of Worcester councilor, Sturbridge man gets probation
-State slaps National Grid over "severe billing errors"
-Aislinn Doyle: Worcester Public Schools in Brief for March
-Assumption President Greg Weiner in New York Times: Colleges have to be much more honest with themselves
-Radio Worcester Roundtable (46:19): Decorum debate and election battles
>DINING OUT (brought to you by Patsie Dugan's): Worcester restaurateurs bring Eddy’s Pub & Sports Bar to Webster Square
-ICYMI: Photographer on mission to capture churches throughout U.S. visits Worcester diocese
-India Society of Worcester's Holi lights up Boston with dance and music
-Gardner auto body shop a total loss after 3-alarm fire (:19). Article
-High Street home in Gardner heavily damaged in early morning fire
-See the rest of the day's Worcester news
>HOLDEN (brought to you by Lamoureux Ford): Wachusett Regional High School honor roll
-Longtime customer salutes Lamoureux Ford (3:53)
-Road closure and traffic delays this week
>THE BURBS (brought to you by North End Motor Sales): Safecam program leads to arrest in Shrewsbury break-in
-From the desk of the Shrewsbury Select Board (2:08)
-Leominster City Council to hold May 12th hearing on proposed horse racing ban
-Spencer Selectmen to discuss scaling back, changing format of override request
-Level school budget headed for Grafton Select Board
-Millbury-Sutton Chronicle goings on
>BARS & BANDS: The Mayor's Live Music List for Tuesday
-Jazzed Up Trio at 961 at Union Station on Wednesday
>SHOWTIME: Lazour brothers to bring "Night Side Songs" to Broadway in Worcester
-Kids free this month at Old Sturbridge Village
-Burncoat High School Theater (38:20): THE PRICE
>OPINION: Worcesteria: From Goddard's homeground, to astronauts' homecoming
-Jennifer Julien Gaskin: The price of denial — RFK Jr., vaccines and the lives on the line
-Amanda Khatib: Getting the help we needed to save our marriage
-Lauren Cilley: A parenting S.O.S. — Our experience using Growing Joy Consulting
-WCCA-TV's Senior Speak No. 922 (28:36)
-Unity Radio's L.A.B.O. News (58:16)
>OBITUARIES: Tribute to local woman who succumbed to early-onset Alzheimer’s at 63
>SPORTS: Celtics beat Grizzlies, 117-103, complete first 6-0 trip in franchise history
-Red Sox drop fourth straight in Orioles home opener, 8-5
-Garrett Crochet agrees to $170 million, 6-year deal with Red Sox
-Former Holy Name star Dwayne McClain looks back at Villanova's NCAA title 40 years ago
-Holy Cross women's basketball assistant Paige Corkins named to Women's Basketball Coaches Association Thirty Under 30 list
-Let the Bravehearts host your P.T.O. fundraiser
-210 Sports' Worcester hockey alumni highlights, NHL week 25
>CARS: Ford, Nissan among over 45,000 vehicles recalled
>NATIONAL: Miami-Dade bus driver shoots, kills 2 passengers: Reports
-Google Chrome confirms cyber "espionage" attacks from "highly sophisticated malware"
>TRAGIC: Transplant patient dies of rabies after receiving donated organ
>NEW ENGLAND: Judge limits third-party culprit defense in Karen Read retrial (2:29)
-$3.4 million in federal food assistance to Mass. cancelled
>COLLEGES: Worcester State gets $250,000 gift to start entrepreneurship competition
-Holy Cross Federalist Society invites Harvard Professor Steven Sachs for constitutional discussion
-WPI students explore careers in sustainability through mentorship program (31:24). Article
>TRAVEL (brought to you by Fuller RV & Rental): The most scenic Amtrak routes in America
>BUSINESS: Mass. Cannabis Commission failed to collect fees of $1.7 million
-LPL Financial Research: Tariff uncertainty facing stocks to start clearing soon
-Worcester Business Journal named best-designed publication, wins 7 New England journalism awards
>HOMES: Autumn Hotaling: Cleaning tips for busy parents
>HEALTH: F.D.A. issues flu vaccine recommendations for 2025-26 season
-Scientists discover "enjoyable way" to lower diabetes risk
-WCCA-TV's Health Matters No. 246 (26:59): Dr. Olga Valdman, Rise Worcester
>TV/STREAMING: "Malcolm In The Middle" set for revival without vital cast member
>MOVIES: 51 best Canadian films of all time
>CELEBRITY: Singer Johnny Mathis to retire, cancels concerts due to "age and memory issues"
>ANIMALS: Puppy who kept being overlooked gets rescued at last minute... (1:41)
>HISTORY: 1903 ad for Royal Worcester corsets
>GOOD NEWS: Painting bought for $2.99 at Goodwill auctioned for $2,875
-Meanwhile, in Germany, parade of 897 wiener dogs breaks Guinness World Record
Latest obituaries | | Monday's highlights | | Today's horoscope | | Local Sports
Classifieds
>HELP WANTED
+Part-time bartender, Patsie Dugan's
+Multiple positions, Holden D.P.W.
-Part-time bartender, Canal District bar
-Servers, Shrewsbury Street restaurant
-Part-time outreach worker, Holden Senior Center
See all Help Wanteds | | Job opening? Post it here for FREE today
Quick Links: Personalize your news | | Browse members | | Advertise | | Blogs | | Invite friends | | Videos
Animals | | Boston Sports | | Business | | Cars | | Celebrity | | Colleges | | Commute & Travel | | Crime | | Faith | | Food | | Good News | | Health | | History | | Homes | | Local Sports | | Lottery | | Movies | | National | | New England | | Politics | | Shopping & Deals | | SHOWTIME! | | TV & Streaming | | Weather
Comments